Standing decisions digest

One line per standing decision, maintained by the daily refresh. The log under agents/logs/ stays the audit trail; this digest never contradicts it. Line format: - YYYY-MM-DD | category | decision | one-line reason or trigger (date = last confirmation).

Scope rulings

#

• 2026-11-07 | spec-driven-development | a language attribution read from default-branch language stats re-opens when the project’s own release notes contradict it; the CLI source branch outranks the stats-only read | archcore’s 10-27 TypeScript correction flipped back to Go on the v0.15.3 release notes (“move the CLI to Go 1.26.10 and Charm v2”), the README Go 1.26+ badge, and the dev-branch tree (328 Go files), main carrying only the plugins and docs

• 2026-11-07 | task-management | the dedicated-list check found no credible task-management-specific list for the third consecutive run, and its incidental candidates routed out on standing rulings | subsy/ralph-tui (2,461 stars, MIT, active) rejected as Ralph-loop wrapper tooling on the 2026-10-28 ruling, orchestration-kind; Nimbalyst (2,036 stars) report-only to cross-category as a visual multi-agent workspace

• 2026-11-07 | task-management | q24 evidence refreshed: no independent adoption or third-party coverage surfaced for TomzxCode/agentic (0 forks, 0 open issues, the coverage search returning only the owner’s own sites) | the rejection stands, the owner-tools exception question stays open

• 2026-11-07 | software-factory | the varun1505 2026-11-02 and 2026-11-05 sweeps resolve with one new admission and the open-swe carry-over landed | Open-Inspect (3,467 stars, MIT, 55 contributors, no releases, zero HN) clears the bar on the open-swe intake-to-PR line; DevBox (312 stars, eleven days old, MIT) holds below the bar on the Orbi coverage precedent with a re-review trigger on coverage or a release; Helix (829 stars, no standard license) rejects beside atomic; DevIntern (4 stars, paid) holds on the thin tail; Volt and Bottleneck are second listings whose rejections carry

• 2026-11-07 | software-factory | the 2026-11-06 open-swe admission landed as its note one run late | the routed note was absent from disk when the 2026-11-07 worklist generated, a carried-pending defect closed the day it surfaced

• 2026-11-07 | trackers-and-leaderboards | the category still keeps no dedicated awesome-list source; the per-refresh check re-ran 2026-11-07 | the strongest literally-dedicated lists stay leoncuhk/awesome-llm-bench (4 stars, still a BenchLM mirror) and metaory/awesome-llm-leaderboards (2 stars), and every new candidate surfaced this run reads 0-1 stars or another category’s kind (gateways, model access, content indexes)

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | agentastic.dev rejects on the thin-record tail: closed product, no public code repository (org holds a 1-star homebrew tap and a 0-star quickstart), an 11-point January Show HN, zero coverage since | resolves the surfaces worker’s terminal-family routing report

• 2026-11-07 | automated-research | matrix membership checks must verify cell content per column, not just cell counts: the 2026-10-29 InternAgent insertion transposed the Harmonic Aristotle and InternAgent cells across seven rows while every row kept its 35-cell count and the header stayed sorted | caught by the one-distinctive-cell-per-column rule; the Lean row’s identical No cells hid the pattern from count-based checks

• 2026-11-07 | automated-research | a repository-level pushed_at on a side branch does not reopen a note whose Status records default-branch activity: autokernel’s 2026-11-05 and formal-math’s 2026-11-01 pushes were side-branch only, both default branches ending at the dates their notes already record | extends the 2026-11-01 default-branch rule from liveness reads to the signal pass itself

• 2026-11-07 | assistant-runtimes | comma (AFK-surf/Comma, 515 stars, AGPL-3.0) rejected on the below-floor thin-record line, the OpenAgent precedent | five weeks old, default branch quiet since 2026-10-27, one human contributor beside a bot, keyword-stuffed description, self-submitted 2-point and 1-point HN stories; reopen on independent coverage or crossing the member floor

• 2026-11-07 | assistant-runtimes | openhuman reads 42,578 stars on 2026-11-07, about +48 in three days (about +16 a day, the slowing trend continuing) against OpenClaw’s 394,100 | the q13 OpenClaw-class scale trigger stays unfired, openhuman held

• 2026-11-07 | code-review | the vendor-run kodustech/awesome-ai-code-review list stays unwired as a mapped source; the category stays on broad sources | staleness re-confirmed 2026-11-07 (pushed_at still 2026-06-28, 54 stars) and a dedicated-list search surfaced nothing credible (largest alternative 155 stars is a system-prompt collection, content under the 2026-10-22 ruling); evidence update for open q21

• 2026-11-07 | skills | a spec repository carrying a working draft of its next version alongside the published version counts as a signal on the published-version claims, not a version change | agent-plugins’ 2026-11-06 push landed spec/1.1.0.md (Working Draft) on main while the published site and the only tag stayed v1.0.0

• 2026-11-07 | skills | a vendor pricing page whose static render drops its published flat-rate figures moves the note’s figures to unverifiable-in-static-fetch rather than to a price change, dated in price history | snyk.io/pricing now renders only the credit-based enterprise model server-side with the Free/Team pane behind client-side rendering

• 2026-11-07 | session-analytics | matrix body rows are verified by content fingerprint against member notes, not by cell count, because the 2026-10-28 twenty-one-column extension inserted NovaFabric’s cells in the agents-observe position and shifted agents-observe through Memex one slot right in all eleven rows while every row kept its correct cell count | insertion-position errors survive count-only checks and pass-touch checks that only edit unshifted columns; alignment now re-derived row by row

• 2026-11-07 | session-analytics | an unreleased main-branch merge that falsifies a matrix reading-prose claim moves the cell to a pending-release qualifier the same run (agentsview’s Provenance ✗ became a pending-release prompt-provenance tilde on PR 2632) | prose claims about what a member does not do rot between releases otherwise

• 2026-11-07 | evaluation-review | benchmark-kind candidates arriving by handoff hold report-only while the agent-benchmarks family question is open | MemPABench (mempabench/mempabench, arXiv 2610.30485, MIT, 2 stars, on-policy personal-agent memory benchmark with paper, code, datasets, and leaderboard) held on it; resolve on the q#85 ruling

• 2026-11-07 | context-engines | the protocols handoff NeuroCode (Arkz-Deepak/neurocode, 0 stars, MIT, created 2026-10-18) rejects on the thin-record tail | context-engine kind confirmed (token-budgeted CPG reachability slicing over MCP) but zero adoption, zero coverage (every HN hit a different same-named project), and self-run benchmarks only; reopen on traction or independent coverage

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | O’Reilly library pages serve a 403 bot wall to non-browser fetches (curl and webfetch both blocked while the URL is valid in browsers), so keep the citation, state the wall in the run’s Changes, and do not replace the source | the hamel-husain rotation re-fetch of oreilly.com/library/view/evals-for-ai/9798341660717/

• 2026-11-07 | model-access | the K3.1 Pro open-weights promise resolved as met, not reopened | moonshotai/Kimi-K3.1-Pro is live on Hugging Face under its own license as of 2026-11-07, fulfilling the promised November 4 release, so the note records the release instead of holding a pending claim

• 2026-11-07 | memory | the TeleAI list’s 2026-10-31 to 11-06 additions resolve on standing families | Engramory (201), MemoSync (186), openJiuwen agent-memory (81), Atris (71), VOOL (12), Counterparts (7), and RE-call (6) below the 294-star floor, Memento (memento-md) a 0-star source-available thin record, bhived and HydraDB closed-hosted hosted products with MCP-server repos only, Comma (514) routed out of memory on the primary-artifact reading (always-on personal agent, memory a subsystem), Cortex/poincare-memory/Executable Agentic Memory/Subgoal-aware Memory Graph paper-section entries, and MemPABench a benchmark routed to evaluation-review

• 2026-11-07 | surfaces | OpenBitFun’s Cowork-style general-workspace rejection holds on the sixth q#14 re-read (the GCWing/OpenBitFun README still pitches a general-purpose agent workspace with Mini App and skins marketplaces and phone remote control, ~3.9k stars, README re-fetched 2026-11-07), the question again reads safe to close | surfaces re-check on the governing question

• 2026-11-07 | surfaces | no credible surfaces-dedicated source has appeared; the best GitHub-search candidates (1shiharat/awesome-agent-clients 16 stars dormant since July 26, dctongsheng/Awesome-Agent-Client 1 star) sit far below the section’s dedicated sources’ adoption | the refresh’s no-dedicated-source check

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | directory listings behind Vercel security checkpoints (everydev.ai class) cite the search-result record that names the listing when unauthenticated fetches 429, on the OpenReview wall precedent | the PandaCode EveryDev.ai listing cited this way this run

• 2026-11-07 | protocols | the 2026-11-03 Personal Agent Protocol admission’s unshipped-v0.1 premise resolved stale: the v0.1 the announcement promised shipped 2026-10-09 as the Poppy draft and the train reached frozen 0.3 (2026-11-04) with draft 0.4 open before the note was written | the note, category index, and matrix column landed 2026-11-07 from live fetches with the corrected Status recorded in the note’s Changes

• 2026-11-07 | protocols | NeuroCode (Arkz-Deepak/neurocode) rejected on the servers-and-utility-layers ruling as an MCP server, context-slicing kind flagged for context-engines routing | 0 stars, created 2026-10-18, surfaced by the awesome-mcp-servers 2026-11-06 addition

• 2026-11-07 | executions | the 2026-11-06 centaur admission landed: note verified out of rotation with every cited URL re-fetched, matrix column and index entry added with the Changes bullet dated to the admission | resolves the coordinator’s interrupted-2026-11-06 handoff

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | PandaCode (aicodeking/pandacode) clears the bar and routes to orchestration on the standalone-ADE line above the 2026-11-01 wave floor | 1,109 stars as of 2026-11-07, daily release train, MIT-plus-fork-attribution license, MindStudio and cnblogs third-party writeups

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | LazyMind (LazyAGI/LazyMind) held out-of-scope pending an owner ruling on knowledge-work skill runtimes | no claiming category after kind declines (skills scope excludes runtimes, not multi-agent orchestration, plugin-into-harness is ecosystem evidence); pctx precedent

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | the andyrewlee 2026-11-05 additions resolve with one admission, one hold, and five below-band rejections; deja-vu and Orchestrator.inc are already-covered listings | caprock 41, devthrottle 110, antumi 97, claudette 87, prometeu 64 stars, all zero-coverage while the tier question is open

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | the 2026-11-06 stars scan pair rejects on the no-agent-story line | spiffe/spire and HewlettPackard/py-spiffe are workload identity infrastructure with no agent surface

• 2026-11-07 | orchestration | repository account/org transfers record in place like renames: note title kept, star-history chart and references moved to the canonical path the same run, the old path named once as history | squad (bradygaster to the github org) and agent-manager (YoanWai to wainmann) both transferred this run, both old paths verified 301

• 2026-11-07 | cross-category | npmjs.com package pages serve a bot wall to plain fetches, so registry.npmjs.org grounds package facts | hit on the oh-my-codex rotation, website 403 while the registry endpoint returned 200; extends the 2026-11-01 unfetchable-page ruling

• 2026-11-07 | section-root | models.dev’s canonical Weights column reading K3.1 Pro Closed is a reference-side disagreement, recorded beside the primaries (Moonshot’s open-weight card, the public Hugging Face release with safetensors and 15 finetunes), never averaged into the cell | the 2026-11-07 fetch flipped the 2026-11-05 Open reading while the primaries still carry the open weights

• 2026-11-06 | orchestration | concord-mcp (Get-Concord-AI/concord-mcp) admitted, the 2026-08-30 concord hold reopened on new independent coverage with the Foremerge/hcom coordination-layer precedent | 978 stars as of 2026-11-06, v0.20.0 (2026-11-05), 5,184 npm downloads in the trailing month, two fetched critical reviews; followagents-style telemetry caution recorded in the note

• 2026-11-06 | cross-category | the coordinator’s 2026-11-05 handoffs resolve with one admission in scope and two routed flags | open-swe (langchain-ai/open-swe, README rebranded to Robin, 11,177 stars, MIT) clears the bar and routes to software-factory on its self-described issue-to-PR factory line (SuperPlane precedent); centaur (paradigmxyz/centaur, 1,422 stars, license verified dual MIT/Apache-2.0) routes to executions on the Airut Slack-to-sandbox precedent

• 2026-11-06 | orchestration | Conductor’s Meta acquisition records in place as the category’s third exit record after Flowise’s archive and Open Swarm’s pivot | joining Meta announced 2026-11-04, cloud read-only 2026-11-13 and shut down 2026-11-20, local maintained to early 2027, 0.93.0 the final release

• 2026-11-06 | protocols | a steward’s own spec hub promoting a version to current counts as shipped maturity for the maturity record even while the tagged implementation train lags behind | A2UI v1.0 promoted to current on a2ui.org (2026-11-06, previously designated as v0.10) while the tagged Python train stays at the 2026-11-02 wave

• 2026-11-06 | cross-category | multi-agent coordination meshes for coding agents (pub/sub spaces, spawn, workflow languages, consoles) are orchestration-kind, not protocols, and stay out below the admitted tier | Cotal (Cotal-AI/Cotal, 381 stars, Apache-2.0) rejected on it; its open-standard framing carries one vendor implementation, no conformance suite, and a 2-point HN story

• 2026-11-06 | cross-category | a young single-vendor protocol suite with one same-company implementation clears the ANP/PIC bar only with exceptional spec form (anchored artifacts, conformance corpus, archived versions, or multi-party implementations) | AMP (agentmessaging/protocol, 37 stars, v0.1.2-draft, providers coming soon) rejected on it; reopen on a second implementation, an adopted provider, or coverage

• 2026-11-06 | cross-category | MCP tool servers providing shared work-state and cross-harness messaging are utility layers, not protocols, whatever their coordination ambition | Get-Concord-AI/concord-mcp (978 stars, MIT) rejected on it as the alternate court

• 2026-11-06 | surfaces | OpenBitFun’s Cowork-style general-workspace rejection holds on the fifth q#14 re-read (the GCWing/OpenBitFun README still pitches a general-purpose agent workspace with Mini App and skins marketplaces and phone remote control, 3,720 stars, pushed 2026-11-06), the question again reads safe to close | surfaces re-check on the governing question

• 2026-11-06 | surfaces | no credible surfaces-dedicated source has appeared; the best GitHub-search candidates (ishandutta2007/Awesome-AI-Code-Editor 18 stars, rsonnet/awesome-agentic-ides 5 stars, pinion05/awesome-agent-ide 4 stars) sit far below the section’s dedicated sources’ adoption | the refresh’s no-dedicated-source check

• 2026-11-05 | control-planes | Speakeasy Gram admitted as the twenty-third member on the coordinator handoff | the public AGPL-3.0 stack (created 2025-08) behind the hosted control plane passes the governs-something test as an identity-and-policy MCP gateway, superseding the 2026-10-10 closed-tier reading and the 2026-10-28 MCP-platform-kind deferral; druce.ai’s wiki entry is the standing critical source

• 2026-11-05 | control-planes | Agent Barn admitted as the twenty-fourth member, the fifth live plane, on the coordinator handoff | per-agent cost attribution, org and per-agent access roles, and audit trails pass the governs-something test; 111 stars is a borderline-traction admission carried by the weekly release train, OECD.AI catalogue coverage, and candid production guides, reopening if the train stalls or coverage retracts

• 2026-11-05 | control-planes | matrix Changes lists restore chronological order when a bullet lands out of sequence | the 2026-10-31 bullet sat after the 2026-11-01 one; moving it to its dated position is the established 2026-10-05 correction convention, recorded in the same run’s bullet

• 2026-11-05 | cross-category | agent SDKs with opt-in OTel tracing export are framework-kind, not evaluation-review | Cognipeer/agent-sdk (7 stars, MIT, pushed 2026-11-03) from the awesome-agent-observability 2026-11-03 additions exports GenAI spans through an otlpSink plugin but judges nothing; flagged for orchestration or harnesses routing

• 2026-11-05 | cross-category | MCP gateways that check tool calls against per-agent contracts and hold writes for approval gate behavior, not output quality | recued/recued (2 stars, AGPL-3.0, self-hosted over mail, calendar, files, and CRM) from the same 2026-11-03 additions is not an evaluation instrument; flagged for protocols or executions routing, thin record regardless

• 2026-11-05 | hybrid-execution | a subject repository’s transfer to its team org re-points the note’s star-history chart and citations in the same run, the note title keeping the established name while an upstream rename is recorded in prose and Status | Valen moved Liuziyu77/Valen to Valen-Team/Valen and renamed itself Valen-Decision in its READMEs on 2026-11-04

• 2026-11-05 | people-and-publications | the humanlayer open-source HITL handoff resolves confirmed, the dex-horthy note’s pivot claim stands and now carries the full deprecation-and-rebuild story | the repo README said “pretty much all deprecated” from 2026-06-19 until the 2026-10-22 pivot commit (d8197bab07), which open-sourced the rebuilt workspace monorepo and preserved the earlier code on the legacy branch and the legacy-final tag

• 2026-11-05 | people-and-publications | the ai-that-works episode list’s PAST/UPCOMING flags lag the episode dates, so airing claims cite the committed episode directory plus the list flag with a date | #79 (2026-10-27) and #80 (2026-11-03) were both still flagged UPCOMING on 2026-11-05 while #79’s airing was already recorded

• 2026-11-05 | cross-category | automated ticker and star-metrics commits do not churn a source for carry-over; only content-addition commits count | hesreallyhim committed eight times a day of ticker data while its last content addition stayed 2026-10-22

• 2026-11-05 | cross-category | enterprise auth/connectors platforms marketed at agents (Scalekit class) reject as out of scope | no category owns generic auth infra

• 2026-11-05 | cross-category | npm’s dated-window download counts backfill upward days later, so weekly-figure citations carry the fetch date | openqodex’s October 25 to 31 week read 1,276 on 2026-11-01 and 1,471 on 2026-11-05 with no release in between

• 2026-11-05 | code-review | vendor announcement posts can be removed wholesale after an acquisition, so vendor-blog citations carry their last-verified date and cite an archived copy when one exists | graphite.com’s Series B/Diamond launch post and joins-Cursor post both 404 as of 2026-11-05 (the joins-Cursor text survives at web.archive.org/web/20261025095730) while the product pages stay live

• 2026-11-05 | automated-research | OpenClaw-ecosystem research IDEs and ResearchClaw variants stay ecosystem tails (dr-claw 1,199 stars, sciClaw, ScienceClaw, research-claw, ResearchClaw x2) | the 2026-10-23 single-harness-port family covers them; none shows independent coverage; dr-claw’s activity is the only reopen signal to watch

• 2026-11-05 | harnesses | Berd (block/berd) folds into the goose note as Block’s desktop sibling | vendor sibling ruling

• 2026-11-05 | control-planes | Okto Nexus folds into the Okto Pulse note | vendor sibling ruling

• 2026-11-05 | software-factory | Claudexor folds into the Ouroboros note (same author, razzant) | vendor sibling ruling

• 2026-11-05 | memory | lettabot archived, succeeded by Letta Code; succession belongs in the Letta note | vendor sibling ruling

• 2026-11-05 | orchestration | herdr derivatives and clients (herduck, Roamgate) fold into the herdr note or reject as derivatives | vendor sibling ruling

• 2026-11-04 | surfaces | OpenBitFun’s Cowork-style general-workspace rejection holds on the fourth q#14 re-read (README still pitches a general-purpose agent workspace with a Mini App marketplace, now 3,462 stars), the q#14 question reads safe to close | surfaces re-check on the governing question

• 2026-11-04 | surfaces | no credible surfaces-dedicated source has appeared; the nearest list candidates (kodustech code-review lists, bradAGI CLI-coding-agents) map to other categories, so surfaces keeps riding the broad sources | the refresh’s no-dedicated-source check

• 2026-10-31 | assistant-runtimes | openhuman reads 42,441 stars on 2026-10-31, about +17 in a day (growth still slowing) against OpenClaw’s 393,510 | the q13 OpenClaw-class scale trigger stays unfired, openhuman held

• 2026-10-31 | code-review | desktop human-review clients for agent PRs judge nothing and are evaluation-review kind on the judges-nothing family | areibman/bottleneck (157 stars, MIT Electron client, zero machine judgment, dormant since 2025-12-04, 2-point Show HN 2025-10-18) held on it; the coordinator handoff had routed it here as code-review-kind

• 2026-10-31 | evaluation-review | areibman/bottleneck admitted as the queue-level judges-nothing review client beside Hunk, PR Lens, and Crit, resolving the code-review handoff | 157 stars, MIT, twelve releases, live installers; dormancy since 2025-12-04 and the 2-point zero-comment Show HN ride the note, reopen the dormancy reading on any push or release

• 2026-10-31 | control-planes | the awesome-ai-governance thin tail grows by two: Agenthof (0 stars) and solvi (4 stars) join the sub-bar open-source tier with the governs-something test already passed, so only traction or coverage reopens them | both gate real actions but have zero independent coverage; keel-verifier resolved separately on the below-the-plane evidence-verifier family and the test checklist on the 2026-10-22 content ruling

• 2026-10-31 | executions | a matrix cell edit re-pads its row back to header width in the same run | the 2026-10-26 n8n and 2026-10-30 Trigger.dev cell edits left the Trigger types and Guardrails rows 17 and 22 characters over header width until the 2026-10-31 pass re-padded them, padding only

• 2026-10-31 | harnesses | a provider API fee attached to a member’s optional integrations lands in that member’s Pricing and Price history, not the matrix | the DeepSeek Search and Fetch fee ($0.75 per 1,000 successful requests, from 2026-11-01) landed on deepseek-harness; the matrix carries no DeepSeek-priced cell

• 2026-10-31 | hybrid-execution | JevBench composite citations carry the method version alongside the board state, since the v1.8 cost re-basing moved self-hosted composites without any member-side signal | Torchcast 4B v1.3 80.5, H2O v1.1 77.9, Winnow Q8 72.21, Kev 27B 71.26, decider-12b v2 73.73 all read differently from the v1.7 basis

• 2026-10-31 | memory | the TeleAI list’s 2026-10-30 to 10-31 additions resolve on standing families | Mnemosyne-28naem-del (154), daimon (21), Okto Neuron (9), and rsh1k/mnemosyne (1) below the 294-star floor, TokenRip closed-hosted with an MIT CLI and no open engine, MAQS an audit checklist (content), MAQS-Way a conformance spec (evaluation-review kind, flagged), World-T3/GESTO/VaM paper-section entries, and akephalos archived upstream with its repository removed

• 2026-10-13 (ruled 2026-10-06) | retrieval | founding scope carries exactly two framework columns (LangChain, LlamaIndex); a third framework is an owner scope call, not an entrant signal | Haystack rejected under it, queue q#4 open

• 2026-10-13 (ruled 2026-10-07) | evaluation-review | founding structure stands: Opik, promptfoo, and AgentOps are third-column or second-framework scope calls, not entrant signals | adoption between existing columns does not override structure, queue q#6 open

• 2026-09-29 (ruled 2026-09-27) | orchestration | category scope includes multi-agent frameworks | owner approved the AMO directory’s in-scope gaps; the framework tier (CrewAI, AutoGPT, AutoGen, Dify, and peers) admitted 2026-09-29

• 2026-10-10 | orchestration | self-evolving workflow frameworks slot in orchestration’s framework family, not automated research | EvoAgentX routed and admitted here

• 2026-09-27 | assistant-runtimes | category scope includes local-first platforms | Open WebUI, AnythingLLM, and PrivateGPT admitted in the stars-scan resolution

• 2026-09-26 | model-access | vendor consumer subscriptions that ship an agent are access products; editor-bundled access (Cursor, Copilot) stays in surfaces pending owner direction | claude-plans and chatgpt-plans admitted on the owner’s reading

• 2026-09-26 | model-access | rejected by kind: consumer assistants without a coding-agent story, pay-per-token inference hosts, enterprise clouds, gray-market discount marketplaces | Poe, Perplexity, Together, Fireworks, Groq, DeepInfra, Bedrock, Vertex, Azure, codingplan.io-style resellers

• 2026-09-27 | model-access | scope includes the self-hosted gateway software layer | litellm admitted; experiential followed the same day

• 2026-10-21 | model-access | serving stacks, chat UIs, engines, and model publishers family-route out of model access | lemonade and llama-swap held as same-slot duplicates; NVIDIA dynamo (datacenter-scale inference serving, starred 2026-10-21) held on the family route; Decision 3.0 (HF model collection) held 2026-10-14

• 2026-10-13 (ruled 2026-10-10) | surfaces | end-user app-building platforms and general-purpose agent workspaces stay out; coding support is the category spine | tambo rejected on the app-building kind call; OpenBitFun rejected as a Cowork-style workspace, queue q#14 open

• 2026-09-12 (ruled 2026-08-24) | orchestration | terminal-family parallel-agent tools and standalone ADEs place in orchestration over surfaces | dmux and claude-squad set it, Conductor and Superset carried it, JetBrains Air applied it

• 2026-09-16 (ruled 2026-08-22) | cross-category | vendor sibling products fold into the sibling note by default | gemini-cli/Antigravity set it; applied to oh-my-pi, Codex App, OpenCode Desktop, Warp Factories, LiteParse, cursor CLI and routines; oh-my-pi left the fold on its own bar clearance 2026-10-10

• 2026-09-21 (ruled 2026-09-18) | hybrid-execution | model-layer members are admissible | Jev entered first; laya superseded the 2026-09-20 wave rejection once the model-layer objection no longer held

• 2026-09-16 | hybrid-execution | engine internals stay cited inside member notes, below the application-layer scope | xgrammar and vLLM structured outputs live inside outlines

• 2026-09-16 | automated-research | closed capability-research instruments qualify where no self-hostable runtime exists | Pion placed here over assistant runtimes

• 2026-10-04 (ruled 2026-09-24) | model-benchmark-matrix | the matrix is model-only: harness benchmarks and harness-variance studies stay out as pointers | FrontierHarness Eval, HarnessTax, JevBench, the Scaffold Effect study

• 2026-10-10 | code-review | review surfaces that judge nothing are evaluation-review members, not code-review | PR Lens shelved beside Hunk; ReviewBench confirmed evaluation-review territory 2026-10-07

• 2026-10-10 | spec-driven-development | entrants route by primary artifact: a spec contract is spec-driven even when tracker-adjacent | Intent-Router shelved here over task management; WrenAI likewise context engines over hybrid execution

• 2026-10-13 (ruled 2026-10-11) | context-engines | archived-by-owner tools are admissible on founding role and scale, not by default | Vanna admitted archived; ByteRover rejected on the distinguished precedent

• 2026-10-07 | protocols | servers and utility layers are not protocols | IBM mcp-context-forge routed to control planes instead (admitted there 2026-10-11); agnix and rulesync rejected

• 2026-10-10 (ruled 2026-10-07) | control-planes | a member must govern something: provenance recorders stay below the plane | git-ai and Invariant rejected on it

• 2026-10-07 | sandboxing | hosted-only services and environment images without an isolation boundary stay out | Deno Sandbox under the Modal precedent; AIO Sandbox an environment image, not a boundary

• 2026-10-10 | executions | data-engineering-first platforms stay out | kestra (29.5k) rejected and re-confirmed as data-engineering-first

• 2026-10-13 (named 2026-10-05) | people-and-publications | a voice is admissible only when their breakout first surfaces inside the section’s coverage window; long-established and interview-only voices fail | applied in every weekly voice scan

• 2026-10-21 | spec-driven-development | the thin-tail precedent (0-10 stars, no independent coverage, reopen on traction or coverage) applies to spec-standard and blueprint kinds | ANSS (6 stars), internal-tool-blueprints (0 stars), one-man-startup (9 stars), and aide (1 star, zero coverage, spec-toolkit kind) rejected on it

• 2026-10-06 | trackers-and-leaderboards | single trend series are not trackers and evals nonprofits are people-category candidates | METR’s time-horizon series rejected as a tracker, queue q#5 open

• 2026-10-17 | memory | the OKF-implementation family folds into the okf-agent-memory note as ecosystem evidence | mcp-memory (218 stars, dormant since 2026-08-30) and Kage held on it

• 2026-10-18 | memory | positional star ranks (“Nth of M members”) are no longer maintained in note prose; the claim churned five correction rounds in two notes and went stale at every admission | memU and screenpipe rank lines dropped

• 2026-10-17 | memory | Vestige pivoted from queryless memory to a fail-closed action firewall (Strata log v4.0.0 landing 2026-09-30, the Operator gate and $149 tier v4.2.0 2026-10-06) and routes out of memory on the primary-artifact reading | admitted to control-planes the same run, 4-point Show HN July 2026 pre-pivot

• 2026-10-17 | skills | the OKF delivery-toolkit kind routes to the memory category’s okf-agent-memory ecosystem family, not to skills (the skills are the delivery mechanism, and OKF packages knowledge about systems, not agent capabilities) | scaccogatto/okf-skills (417 stars) folded there 2026-10-17

• 2026-10-21 | evaluation-review | lukstei/slop-grader admitted as the document-and-diff grader beside Jevals, the category’s second Jev-based member | skills-worker handoff resolved on the citation bar; the thin one-thread HN footprint is stated in the note, on the HermesGate precedent

• 2026-10-21 | spec-driven-development | context-engineering layers route here when the artifact is a typed spec set plus a convergence check that names the guilty side | archcore admitted on the Intent-Router primary-artifact precedent; the looptroop-ai/LoopTroop duplicate admission was retracted the same run, the orchestration member stands as the primary frame

• 2026-10-21 | control-planes | Tracekit admitted as the category’s eleventh gate at 138 stars | governs calls before execution with a CT-style witness-cosigned evidence log, unlike any member; the experimental no-public-witness gap is stated in the note

• 2026-10-22 | hybrid-execution | the Decision Index 0.4 Full score is fully private (60 percent same-skills, 40 percent new-domains, the public index shown but uncounted), so member rows cite the 0.4.1 reading | board regenerated 2026-10-22 with 226 configurations, GLiDE V1.2 first at 71.52, Jev 1.14 forty-first

• 2026-10-22 | hybrid-execution | TypeChat’s npm-publication reopen trigger counts a revival-era publication only, not the pre-revival npm line | the npm typechat package (latest 0.1.4, 2026-08-21) predates the 2026-10-13 revival push, asked in queue

• 2026-10-22 | cross-category | npm weekly download figures carry zero-day gaps, so adoption claims prefer the trailing-month window | context7’s npm week to 2026-10-18 reported 482,795 with three zero days inside the window while the trailing month read 2,640,895

• 2026-10-22 | cross-category | notch supervision surfaces, passive notification and approval-forwarding UIs over orchestration members, reject as tails under the mission-control dashboards-and-tails family | perch (asafofer/perch, 22 stars, zero coverage) held on it

• 2026-10-22 | cross-category | guides, cookbooks, prompt references, and pattern collections are content, not tools, and stay unprofiled regardless of scale | the unmatched broad-source tail (claude-howto 42.5k, claude-code-system-prompts 13k, loop-engineering 11.6k, infrastructure-showcase 10k) reads out on it

• 2026-10-23 | automated-research | single-harness personal autoresearch ports with no independent coverage stay unprofiled | the webfuse-com/awesome-autoresearch scan’s pi/mlx/webgpu/sudoku-class tail read out on it

• 2026-10-23 | cross-category | benchmark and evaluation-harness repositories are not research loops and route to evaluation-review | the webfuse-com scan surfaced mle-bench, AgentBench, MLAgentBench, ML-Bench, and mlrbench

• 2026-10-23 | automated-research | dormant members below 500 stars with no independent coverage close until new coverage lands, per the concord-and-huzzah rule | applied to Sibyl-Research-Team/AutoResearch-SibylSystem, MLR-Copilot, ResearchAgent, ML-Agent, autoresearcher, self_improving_coding_agent

• 2026-10-23 | evaluation-review | a member’s subject repository moving to a redirecting path is a note-level provenance fact, not a scope change | hermes-labs-ai/hermes-gate now redirects to roli-lpci/hermes-gate; the note’s twin-repo caution was rewritten to the present fact in rotation

• 2026-10-25 | automated-research | a member repository’s transfer into an institutional organization is a recorded note fact, with the star-history chart and references moved to the canonical path the same run | AutoSci moved from skyllwt to PKU-DAIR (the Peking University DAIR lab of senior author Bin Cui), old URLs redirect and the README still points at them

• 2026-10-23 | model-access | upstream -pro model ids (OpenAI GPT-5.6/6 Sol/Luna/Terra Pro) are provider-side serving tiers, not aggregator-only lines; the category records them in openrouter with the same-price-more-reasoning-tokens cost trap named | resolved the 2026-10-22 section-root sighting on OpenRouter endpoints evidence (OpenAI flex/fast/ultrafast and Azure endpoints, dated snapshot ids, base-identical pricing)

• 2026-10-25 | trackers-and-leaderboards | bestvaluemodel admitted, resolving the 2026-09-25 reopen-on-license line | a month of six-hourly refreshes with daily data diffs, still fully derivative of member Artificial Analysis with credit, and the single-source caveat stands

• 2026-10-28 | trackers-and-leaderboards | the category still keeps no dedicated awesome-list source | the per-refresh check re-ran 2026-10-28; the strongest new candidate (tatn/awesome-ai-benchmarks, 7 stars) sits far below the other categories’ mapped sources, and the BenchGecko and leoncuhk rejections stand

• 2026-10-25 | context-engines | a pushed-signal that resolves to non-default-branch activity, no main-branch commit and no release, is non-material and leaves the note untouched | entroly, SoL-Pi, and repowise pushes on 2026-10-25 all read out as agent/*-branch activity over mains last touched 2026-10-16 to 2026-10-20

• 2026-10-25 | executions | version-gated claims cite only gates still present on the live doc page at re-verification | the hooks v2.1.214 if directory-pattern gate and the routines v2.1.213 trust-model gate both aged out of the live docs within a month of being cited

• 2026-10-25 | hybrid-execution | the Jeff name on the JevBench board belongs to jgeuter’s unrelated Gemma-4-31B fine-tune, so board credits in member notes check the row’s Hugging Face owner before citing | the 10-15 and 10-20 jeff bullets credited the family with a row that was never its, corrected 2026-10-25

• 2026-10-25 | hybrid-execution | member notes citing JevBench capability standings carry their board revision, since method v1.7’s 10-second rule re-ranked every row on its landing (H2O-Lightning-31B v1.0.7 first at 84.3, Chon-1.0-12B from first to rank 30 in one day) | board v1.7.48 fetched 2026-10-25

• 2026-10-25 | cross-category | the andyrewlee 2026-10-24 addition bdots holds on the assistant-runtimes absorbed runtime family (renamed upstream to fayazara/coworkers 2026-10-28, 306 stars, the rejection carries by mechanism) | a Cloudflare-native personal multi-bot runtime, the cloudflare-os slot; zero independent coverage, reopen on q#13, OpenClaw-class scale, or coverage

• 2026-10-25 | cross-category | the ai-for-developers list’s Code Review section resolved in full (twenty-two entries, all rejections or already-covered); its remaining sections and the other broad sources’ back catalogs get a one-off unresolved-entries walk | the 2026-10-25 sweep found ten never-resolved entries hiding in a source the scanner reads, so carry-over-on-commit-history misses back-catalog entries

• 2026-10-23 | session-analytics | CodexMonitor admitted as the category’s first dormant member; dormancy within two months of a vendor surface launch is the note’s finding, not a rejection reason | the 4,348-star Codex command center went quiet days after Hacker News compared it with the official Codex app

• 2026-10-23 | session-analytics | ax’s session-graph core makes it session-analytics despite the repository’s observability-plus-memory self-description | the memory half is session-derived introspection (retro loop, AGENTS.md fixes, skill triage), not a cross-project memory layer

• 2026-10-23 | spec-driven-development | a renamed-and-rebranded candidate re-resolves on current evidence; the old rejection carries by mechanism, not by name | BusinessLens rejected below the bar 2026-10-13, admitted as pdd-kit on the rebrand, the shipped site, and continued daily development

• 2026-10-23 | task-management | ccpm admitted as the category’s forge-native kind | coordinator handoff resolved; MIT skill running PRDs onto GitHub Issues with worktree parallelism, 8,414 stars, a 175-point Show HN thread, and independent critical coverage clear the citation bar

• 2026-10-23 | trackers-and-leaderboards | the category keeps no dedicated awesome-list source; the broad sources suffice | the two candidates found 2026-10-23 fail the bar, BenchGecko/awesome-llm-benchmarks stale since creation 2026-03-27, leoncuhk/awesome-llm-bench a daily mirror of member BenchLM

• 2026-10-23 | cross-category | the andyrewlee 2026-10-22 additions resolve on standing families | Delegatus on the thin-record tail, deepseek-harness-action as wrapper tooling on an unprofiled subject, Harness by Autonomous routed to orchestration on the standalone-ADE precedent (admission resolved by the next run)

• 2026-10-26 | cross-category | star-history chart markup: only the dark source in a picture block carries theme=dark, never the light source or the img fallback | coordinator handoff; the 2026-10-25 pass fixed the img fallbacks but left light sources carrying theme=dark across five categories, all fixed 2026-10-26

• 2026-10-26 | cross-category | a subject board’s page drifting under an unchanged revision number counts as a signal and re-verifies board-citing notes out of rotation | the jev rotation re-fetch found JevBench v1.7.48 grown from 220 to 227 ranked open-weights and 47 to 48 API rows since the 10-25 fetch

• 2026-10-26 | cross-category | Hugging Face download counts are rolling-window figures that swing both ways, so rotation refreshes them with a fresh as-of date and reads no trend into a swing | decider-2b read 334,268 on 10-18 and 164,599 on 10-26 with no release in between

• 2026-10-26 | skills | the rea.tools scale record grew from the 109.9k recorded 2026-10-13 to 387,014 stars (morluto/rea, fetched 2026-10-26), now the largest known skills-adjacent record and still outside on the standing exclusion pending q#11 and q#20 | the VoltAgent/awesome-agent-skills scan surfaced the repo as a new entry indexing one of its skill directories

• 2026-10-26 | software-factory | the ahmadyan/awesome-software-factory list (2 stars, single-day push, maintainer self-promotes Agentastic.dev) stays below the dedicated-source bar and is not adopted as a mapped source | its entries cross-check to known members, already-resolved subjects, or other categories’ kinds

• 2026-10-26 | spec-driven-development | acceptance-test and QA harnesses route to evaluation-review under the primary-artifact rule | vostride/agent-qa (895 stars, FSL-1.1-ALv2, self-published AndroidWorld and AppControlBench results) authors and runs acceptance tests, not spec contracts

• 2026-10-27 | cross-category | npm’s point/last-month downloads endpoint can serve a stale window (June reads on October 27 across harnesses, protocols, and context engines), so refreshes use dated-range queries (api.npmjs.org/downloads/point/:) and range sums whenever the point response’s window dates lag today | ag-ui, repomix, copilot-cli, and bullet all read stale or wrong figures from point endpoints before range sums corrected them

• 2026-10-27 | surfaces | OpenBitFun stays out on the Cowork-style general-purpose workspace rejection and the q#14 re-read found the same self-described workspace with a Mini App marketplace, so the question reads closable | surfaces re-check on the governing question

• 2026-10-27 | surfaces | a vendor with a dual identity files by its desktop editor kind, folding the sibling product in as prose | puppyone admitted as an agent editor even though its own docs pitch a Context File System

• 2026-10-27 | memory | the Meirtz-list handoff portable-ai-memory/python-sdk, the PAM interchange spec’s SDK, stays below the bar | 1 star, dormant since 2026-02-19, spec repo 12 stars, NOASSERTION license, zero independent coverage, providers do not natively support the format; reopen on traction or coverage

• 2026-10-27 | evaluation-review | vostride/agent-qa admitted as the acceptance-test column; the 2026-10-12 dormancy hold triggered on the 2026-10-24 push and three releases | citation bar cleared in-run with the docs hub, CI guide, both self-published benchmark pages with per-task evidence, the FSL license text, npm SLSA provenance, and the 50-point launch thread; the vendor-run benchmark caveat rides the note like FrontierHarness Eval

• 2026-10-27 | cross-category | run-recording, replay, and causal-analysis repositories are session-analytics kind, not evaluation-review | Psionic-labs/Agent-Causality and MSKazemi/novafabric routed there; they re-run and slice recorded runs, they judge nothing

• 2026-10-28 | assistant-runtimes | openhuman stays held on the absorbed-family shelf, the q13 OpenClaw-class scale trigger as framed still unfired | tinyhumansai/openhuman read 42,378 stars on 2026-10-28 against 42.2k on 10-21 (about +180 in a week) while OpenClaw reads 393k

• 2026-10-28 | model-access | a member note’s recorded pricing-page rebuild moves that note’s matrix cells in the same run, not only membership changes do | the experiential 2026-10-24 flat-plan rebuild reached the note and price table but left the matrix’s billing-mechanics, top-tier, and price-trajectory cells stale until this pass caught them

• 2026-10-28 | people-and-publications | pauldambra.dev rejected as a voice: the flagged “Machinists > Tailors” post surfaced at 2 HN points and 0 comments and no independent coverage, so the coverage-window bar is unmet | reopen on independent coverage of any agent-era post

• 2026-10-28 | software-factory | varun1505/awesome-software-factories (42 stars) remains the only dedicated software-factory list above the bar | the 2026-10-28 search surfaced only single-star single-author lists beside the already-rejected ahmadyan list

• 2026-10-28 | section-root | the section index’s verified stamps, member counts, and newest-column claims are synced mechanically from each category matrix’s own updated date, header row, and Changes tail whenever the section-root worker holds the index | the 2026-10-27 interrupted run updated category matrices without an index pass, leaving ten counts and twelve newest claims stale against the matrices they describe

• 2026-10-30 | assistant-runtimes | LangBot admitted as the category’s sixteenth member from the new elyase/awesome-personal-ai-assistants scan | Apache-2.0 IM-bot platform in the AstrBot kind, 18,601 stars above the Octop floor, weekly v4.11 cadence, PyPI Production/Stable, the zero-English-footprint signal stated in the note

• 2026-10-30 | assistant-runtimes | the elyase list’s claw-named tail (MimiClaw 5.8k, IronClaw 12.7k, OpenBrowserClaw, MyClaw, SubZeroClaw, Clawlet, and Cloudflare’s MoltWorker) holds on the absorbed-family shelf by mechanism, and its non-claw assistants (moltis 2.9k, Picobot 1.3k, Sentient, Gaia, rho, the archived lettabot and clawlet, the dormant personal-ai-assistant and MARVIN) reject on the OpenAgent floor or thin records | one scan, no new rulings needed

• 2026-10-30 | assistant-runtimes | openhuman reads 42,424 stars on 2026-10-30, about +46 in two days (slower than the +180-per-week recorded 10-28) against OpenClaw’s 393k | the q13 OpenClaw-class scale trigger stays unfired, openhuman held

• 2026-10-30 | code-review | the vendor-run kodustech/awesome-ai-code-review list stays unwired as a mapped source; the category stays on broad sources | staleness re-confirmed 2026-10-30 (pushed_at still 2026-06-28) and no credible dedicated list has appeared (largest dedicated candidates 1 to 2 stars); updates the 2026-10-24 line’s evidence for open q21

• 2026-10-30 | control-planes | rotation re-verifications record a ## Changes bullet even with no drift | the work list derives last_verified from the newest Changes bullet, so a silent pass never advances and the same notes re-rotate; seven notes already followed this convention before this run

• 2026-10-29 | section-root | The section-root essays’ star-count and install-count prose (Orca, Claude Code, OpenCode, DeepSeek Harness, Kimi Code, Cline) stops refreshing under the stars exemption; the existing dated figures stand | the dispatch restates “stars never refresh anywhere” and the essays’ older daily star refreshes contradict it, so the prose counts freeze at their last dated values.

• 2026-10-29 | section-root | A pure delta-pass re-dates the tracker’s as-of clause only when a fact moved | zero-move runs (this one for five of seven provider pages) leave the as-of anchored to the last change date, matching the 2026-10-21 and 2026-10-23 precedent.

• 2026-10-29 | trackers-and-leaderboards | the category still keeps no dedicated awesome-list source; the per-refresh check re-ran 2026-10-29 | the only literally-dedicated list (metaory/awesome-llm-leaderboards, created 2026-09-10) reads 2 stars, below even the rejected 7-star tatn candidate, and the credible new benchflow-ai/awesome-evals (1,017 stars) is evaluation-infrastructure kind, not trackers

• 2026-10-29 | automated-research | the InternScience org scan resolves with one admission, one sibling fold, and the benchmark route | InternAgent admitted with MLEvolve folded in as its optimization subsystem; Dolphin, DiscoveryOS, and Virtual-Scientists closed on the dormant-below-500 rule until coverage lands; SGI-Bench routed to evaluation-review on the benchmark family

• 2026-10-29 | assistant-runtimes | openhuman stays held on the absorbed-family shelf, the q13 OpenClaw-class scale trigger as framed still unfired | tinyhumansai/openhuman read 42,403 stars on 2026-10-29 against 42,378 on 10-28 (about +25 a day) while OpenClaw reads 393k

• 2026-10-30 | executions | rotation re-verifies read the subject’s product changelog, not just the repo API: Trigger.dev’s inbound-webhooks beta (2026-10-26) invalidated the note’s and the matrix’s no-webhooks claims between passes, and only the changelog page surfaced it

• 2026-10-30 | executions | no credible dedicated executions source has appeared as of 2026-10-30; the category keeps riding the broad sources

• 2026-10-30 | harnesses | the pi port wave routed from the assistant-runtimes scan (Dicklesworthstone/pi_agent_rust 1.9k, joelreymont/pz, philipp-spiess/modern, matteing/opal) resolves on the wrapper-tooling-on-a-member mechanism, the 2026-10-28 Ralph-loop precedent, with pi_agent_rust folded into the pi note as ecosystem evidence | ports, rewrites, and GUIs of an existing member are that member’s ecosystem evidence, not standalone harnesses

• 2026-10-28 | cross-category | the andyrewlee 2026-10-27 additions resolve on standing families and one handoff | hotline and open-walnut on the thin-record tail, agentglass on the mission-control tail, Scalekit on the closed-tier line, Speakeasy Gram on the MCP-platform kind (superseded by its 2026-11-05 admission), CAO (awslabs/cli-agent-orchestrator, 1.5k) handed to orchestration on the OpenHarness precedent

• 2026-10-28 | cross-category | the six broad sources’ back catalogs are fully walked and carry-over-on-commit-history gaps are closed | 950 never-matched entries resolved in one pass: 93 dead links, the rest on standing families; the largest new records read onto open questions (andrej-karpathy-skills 225.6k content, archify 90.6k single skill, learn-claude-code 79.4k content, claude-hud 28.9k tail, claude-obsidian 15.9k memory-kind handoff)

• 2026-10-28 | cross-category | same-kind multi-agent frameworks below the admitted tier’s adoption stay out while the tier question is open | swarms 7.3k, agency-swarm 4.6k, langroid 4.1k rejected on it; ChatDev 34.6k (active 2.0) handed to orchestration as the one scale-and-activity exception

• 2026-10-28 | cross-category | the Ralph-loop cluster is wrapper tooling on the claude-code member, ecosystem-evidence kind | ralph-claude-code 9.7k is the head; pattern writeups are content under the 2026-10-22 ruling

• 2026-10-31 | cross-category | HN Algolia search citations need the query re-checked at re-fetch, because loose query strings silently stop matching while the cited threads still exist | the bernstein reference (query=bernstein.run&tags=story) returned zero hits while query=bernstein&tags=show_hn returned the cited 1-point Show HN; the claim stood, the URL no longer grounded it

• 2026-10-31 | orchestration | a member’s product rename records in place (note title kept), with the star-history chart and references moved to the canonical path the same run; a retitle is an owner call | superset-sh/superset renamed to ParadevAI/Paradev, README headlines “Paradev (formerly Superset)”; retitle question appended to the queue

• 2026-10-31 | surfaces | OpenBitFun’s Cowork-style general-workspace rejection holds on the third q#14 re-read (the README still pitches a general-purpose agent workspace with a Mini App marketplace, now 3,423 stars), so the question reads safe to close | surfaces re-check on the governing question

• 2026-10-31 | task-management | the dedicated-list check’s incidental candidates resolve on the thin-record tail without a mapped-source scan | rasimme/FlowBoard (96 stars) and DanWahlin/ai-agent-board (67 stars) surfaced in a dedicated-list websearch, both zero independent coverage

• 2026-10-31 | trackers-and-leaderboards | the category still keeps no dedicated awesome-list source; the per-refresh check re-ran 2026-10-31 | the strongest new candidates are brandonhimpfen/awesome-ai-benchmarks-evaluation (14 stars, active 2026-10-07) and git-git-hurrah/awesome-llm-leaderboards (6 stars, stale since April), both far below the other categories’ mapped sources, and onejune2018/Awesome-LLM-Eval (659 stars) is evaluation-kind and stale since 2025-11

• 2026-10-31 | trackers-and-leaderboards | the Vectara board’s published rankings are computed by the commercial HHEM-2.3, with HHEM-2.1-Open as the downloadable open variant | the README and model card state it in plain text; the note, three matrix cells, the verification prose, and the index one-liner corrected 2026-10-31

• 2026-10-31 | cross-category | the andyrewlee and AMO 2026-10-29 to 10-31 additions resolve on standing families | nine thin-record tails held (wsp, volt, borg, lookout, pohunek, yardlet, MercuryCLI, Aixle Flow, sorcerer), alchemist-coder’s AMO-wave rejection carried by mechanism on the second listing, herdr-core and herduck folded into the herdr member as ecosystem evidence

• 2026-10-31 | orchestration | Commonly (Team-Commonly/commonly, 1,374 stars as of 2026-10-31) admitted on the OpenHarness standalone-ADE precedent, the zero-coverage signal stated | Apache-2.0 self-hostable team pod sharing one task board and conversations with each member’s agents, added to AMO’s Coordination And Team Systems 2026-10-30, v3.0.0 2026-10-28

• 2026-11-01 | cross-category | the AMO 2026-10-30 to 11-01 additions resolve with one thin-tail rejection and two already-covered listings | Joxo (89 stars, closed-source hosted, plugin-only repo, zero coverage) rejected on the thin-record tail; the #97 Google AX listing is the orchestration ax member’s own repository and #99 is a Herdr entry upgrade, no membership change

• 2026-11-01 | section-root | Superset is now Paradev (ParadevAI/Paradev, Elastic License 2.0, “formerly Superset” per its own README, CLI still superset); treat any remaining Superset mentions in essays as Paradev | repository README fetched 2026-11-01

• 2026-11-01 | section-root | Paseo is Apache-2.0, relicensed from the AGPL-3.0 earlier records carry, with Antigravity and Muse Code added to its provider roster | repository README fetched 2026-11-01

• 2026-11-01 | model-access | a vendor page contradicting itself between its plan table and its own FAQ/example text is recorded with both readings and the disagreement named, never averaged into one number | the experiential 2026-11-01 fetch read 10M/100M/1B tokens-a-day ceilings in the plan table against the FAQ’s retained 9B/36B/54B, so the note and matrix carry both with dates

• 2026-11-01 | people-and-publications | ludicity (Nik Suresh, Hermit Tech) rejected as a voice on the long-established clause of the 2026-10-13 ruling: the author’s breakout essays predate the coverage window, so the July 2026 AI Mania coverage is not an in-window breakout | the essay itself remains admissible as third-party evidence inside member notes

• 2026-11-01 | protocols | a community SDK merged to main counts as shipped for the note’s Status even while the README and docs tables lag | ag-ui’s Swift SDK (PR #1512, 2026-10-31) landed in sdks/community/swift with the README table not yet naming it; recorded in Status with the lag noted

• 2026-11-01 | sandboxing | the arjan/awesome-agent-sandboxes back catalog is fully walked and its carry-over gap is closed | the 2026-10-09 walk had logged only its two admissions, so twenty-two unmatched entries resolved this run on standing families, dormancy, or kind, with two cross-category flags (rivet-dev/sandbox-agent, portofcontext/pctx)

• 2026-11-01 | sandboxing | a subject’s self-published coordinated-disclosure record is disclosure evidence, not an audit, wherever its audit status is stated | nono now carries fifteen advisories since May 2026 including the CVE-2026-47128 D-Bus systemd-run sandbox escape and four high-severity bypasses, recorded in its note and the matrix’s audit prose

• 2026-11-01 | cross-category | OpenReview forum and API pages serve a bot-check wall to unauthenticated fetches, so venue-acceptance claims cite the fetched page that records the citation instead of the unfetchable forum URL | the EvoSkill rotation grounded the Agent Skills ‘26 workshop acceptance (ACM CAIS 2026) in the fetched v2 branch README after openreview.net/forum?id=i4b4As7RFX and its api2 endpoint both returned the verification wall

• 2026-11-01 | software-factory | camplight/awesome-software-factories (8 stars, pushed 2026-10-28) joins the below-the-bar dedicated-list set beside the ahmadyan rejection | single-author list at trivial adoption; varun1505 (55 stars) remains the only list above the bar

• 2026-11-01 | spec-driven-development | MCP-server spec workflows resolve on the primary-artifact rule; mcp-probe-kit admitted at 41 stars as the protocol-native kind with zero coverage stated | the converge gate’s artifact is a spec-plus-evidence chain, not tracker state, and the admission rides the Mycelium no-membership-floor precedent rather than the thin-tail band

• 2026-11-01 | spec-driven-development | declarative UI screen specs consumed by a design renderer’s layout engine are design-surface tooling, not spec-driven development | DESIGN:OS Studio (jangtrinh/design-os-studio, 81 stars, PolyForm Shield, zero coverage) rejected on it and reported for surfaces

• 2026-11-01 | task-management | a repository’s own pricing claim defers to the vendor’s live article when the two disagree | automaker’s README still advertises the Claude Agent SDK credit pool effective 2026-06-15 that Anthropic’s article (updated 2026-10-07) records as paused, with subscription limits still applying

• 2026-11-01 | task-management | the dedicated-list check found no credible task-management-specific list again, and GitHub topic-page incidental candidates route by primary artifact | builderz-labs/mission-control (control-plane kind) and Chorus-AIDLC/Chorus (harness kind) surfaced in the topics page and routed out of the category

• 2026-11-01 | harnesses | zcode desktop release versions read from GitHub releases, not the JS-rendered product site | the 2026-11-01 rotation could no longer extract an installer version from zcode.z.ai by direct fetch, so the note cites GitHub releases (v3.17.1, published October 30)

• 2026-11-01 | cross-category | a repository-level pushed_at can move on side-branch pushes while the default branch sits dormant, so a pushed date read as a liveness signal checks the default branch’s latest commit | hermes-gate’s 2026-10-29 push was a dependabot bump with the default branch quiet since 2026-09-29; kiln, kitaru, and ReviewBench showed the same pattern this run

• 2026-11-01 | evaluation-review | pypi.org project pages serve a bot challenge to plain fetchers, so version and publish-date claims ground through the pypi.org/pypi//json endpoint | hermes-gate’s cited project page challenge-blocked the re-fetch while the JSON endpoint returned 0.1.7 (2026-09-19); the browser-canonical URL stays cited

• 2026-11-01 | executions | rivet-dev/sandbox-agent URLs are the rivet-agents member repository itself (renamed upstream; the path 301s to rivet-dev/agents) | resolves the 2026-11-01 handoff without a new note and stops future source listings of the old name from re-surfacing it

• 2026-11-01 | assistant-runtimes | accomplish-ai/coworker, the kaushikb11 list’s “Openwork” row, rejected as a dead tombstone and confirmed not the renamed fayazara/coworkers rejection | the coworkers repo still exists unchanged (358 stars, pushed 2026-11-01), and the coworker repo holds only a “no longer supported” README, no code, 10,824 vestigial stars, dormant since 2026-08-13

• 2026-11-01 | automated-research | ARIS’s mainline skill count reads as skills/ directories carrying SKILL.md, not the raw directory count | the raw listing holds 91 directories (skill packs and shared-references bundles included) while 87 carry SKILL.md, so reading 91 as a correction of the recorded 87 would be wrong

• 2026-11-01 | code-review | the vendor-run kodustech/awesome-ai-code-review list stays unwired as a mapped source; the category stays on broad sources | staleness re-confirmed 2026-11-01 (pushed_at still 2026-06-28) and a repository search for dedicated lists surfaced only single tools (largest 257 stars, no curated list); evidence update for open q21

• 2026-11-01 | control-planes | builderz-labs/mission-control admitted as the fourth live plane on the task-management routing | the Aegis approval record on done plus the opt-in dispatch sandbox flags govern the task lifecycle, which the mission-control dashboards-and-tails family fails; the changelog’s own no-policy-engine line is the stated boundary, reopen only on a policy engine shipping

• 2026-11-01 | surfaces | the ai-for-developers list’s two long-unresolved surfaces candidates reject on the thin-record tail | BBARIT (binary distribution ended 2026-10-18, pointer repo at 40 stars over a 13-star source drop, zero coverage) and Bodega One Code (closed source, distribution repos at 47 and 2 stars, licensing undecided, zero coverage)

• 2026-11-01 | orchestration | the 2026-11-01 topic-page ADE wave admits six members on the standalone-ADE and terminal-family lines with the missing-footprint signal stated per note | agtx, Cezar, Chorus, Happier, nodeterm, and termio admitted from the github.com/topics/ade and topics/parallel-agents sighting; coverage is zero (happier, nodeterm, agtx, termio) or launch-echo (Chorus 3 points, Cezar 15 points)

• 2026-11-01 | orchestration | single-harness SDKs whose kernel runs its own agent loop with model routing are not multi-agent orchestration regardless of topic-page placement | loushang (zhnt/loushang, 1,939 stars) rejected, no parallel/multi-agent/worktree surface, team workflows a roadmap item

• 2026-11-01 | orchestration | topic-page candidates below the wave’s own zero-coverage floor (termio at 751 stars) reject on the below-band line while the tier question is open | Pane 595, vicoa 523, wmux 440, agentbox 336, mulmoterminal 256, operator-oss 208, rove 181, tlbx 116, agetor 110, and cleancode 108 rejected 2026-11-01; one tier ruling re-resolves the tail in a single pass

• 2026-11-01 | orchestration | kyrolabs/awesome-ade is a credible dedicated mapped source for the category (25 stars, 18 member entries, actively pushed, curation depth above the admitted varun1505 bar) | wiring and its back-catalog walk are owner calls, queued 2026-11-01

• 2026-11-01 | spec-driven-development | compressed spec plugins for one harness are SDD kind, but the caveman-family personal-bundle hold applies | cavekit (JuliusBrussee/cavekit, 1,156 stars) routed report-only from orchestration, frozen August 2026, development moved to caveman

• 2026-11-01 | cross-category | portofcontext/pctx closed out of scope with no claiming category after four kind declines (sandboxing, protocols, executions, hybrid-execution) | the Code-Mode tool-execution substrate question queued for the owner on the heretic precedent

• 2026-11-03 | cross-category | the andyrewlee 2026-11-02 additions resolve with two admissions routed and three rejections | kanzo (921 stars, board plus MCP) routed to task-management, Cloudroom (1,311 stars, GUI built on the bb member) routed to orchestration on the standalone-ADE line, Friday (29), Agora (5), and TaskHandoff (5) rejected on the thin-record below-band line while the tier question is open

• 2026-11-03 | cross-category | the 2026-11-01 protocols handoff resolves one admission and one rejection | Personal Agent Protocol (Sierra and Meta with Genesys, Instinct, Rocket, Shopify, Stripe, Walmart; HN 9 points) clears the bar with the unshipped v0.1 spec as its Status fact and beri.net as the critical source; toqprotocol/toq (6 stars, pushed 2026-03-18, 0-comment Show HN) fails on the thin dormant record, reopen on traction or coverage

• 2026-11-03 | cross-category | reading and book tools reject on the no-agent-story scope line regardless of stars | tudorms/BookScan (2 stars, dormant) and bookorbit/bookorbit (6,104 stars) serve readers, not engineers working with agents; the browser-automation precedent holds at scale

• 2026-11-03 | cross-category | the matrix contract’s header width means cell-count parity, not character width; sourced cells are never truncated to fit a column’s padding, a longer cell leaves its row wider | the retrieval worker’s 2026-11-03 ruling request; every recent commit already keeps each row’s own width stable

• 2026-11-03 | cross-category | jackjin1997/markindex held out of retrieval on the thin-record tail | 1 star, 11 days old, vectorless Markdown retrieval MCP server surfaced by the protocols source; reopen on traction

• 2026-11-03 | section-root | DeepSeek’s Search-and-Fetch pricing notice kept its free-of-charge wording through the 2026-11-03 read, three days past its stated 2026-11-01 start; the guide and matrix sentences already carry the dated clock, so no cell moved | pricing page fetched 2026-11-03

• 2026-11-03 | section-root | the Claude Code context-window doc now organizes compaction survival per mechanism and names idle compaction (a session left idle compacts on its own) | docs fetched 2026-11-03

• 2026-11-03 | retrieval | Danielskry/Awesome-RAG stays a mapped source: quiet since 2026-10-06 but reachable with entry overlap intact, quiet alone does not meet the staleness bar | the 2026-11-03 handoff re-check fetched the API, commit history, and README

• 2026-11-04 | cross-category | the andyrewlee 2026-11-02 additions of Flue, sandcastle, and Mastra are already-covered listings (withastro/flue a sandboxing member, mattpocock/sandcastle and mastra-ai/mastra orchestration members), closing the 2026-11-03 line’s under-report of the source’s eight additions | verified in-run against the README entry repositories and membership

• 2026-11-04 | cross-category | the AMO 2026-11-04 additions resolve with no new rulings: Friday (splashxmoon/friday) is the andyrewlee Friday’s second listing and its thin-record below-band rejection carries by mechanism, and SpaceApp’s MIT-license update adds no traction or coverage so the thin-record rejection does not reopen | one scan, no new rulings needed

• 2026-11-04 | cross-category | the stars scan’s ydb-platform/nbs rejects on the no-agent-story scope line | network block devices and POSIX filesystem over YDB BlobStorage, storage data-infrastructure with no agent surface (113 stars, C++, Apache-2.0 as of 2026-11-04)

• 2026-11-04 | assistant-runtimes | openhuman reads 42,530 stars on 2026-11-04, about +89 in four days (about +22 a day, in line with the slowing trend) against OpenClaw’s 393,870 | the q13 OpenClaw-class scale trigger stays unfired, openhuman held

Standing family rejections

#

• 2026-10-12 (ruled 2026-10-07) | orchestration | single-vendor agent-building SDKs rejected as SDKs, not multi-agent orchestration systems | openai-agents-python, smolagents, adk-python, semantic-kernel, strands, claude-agent-sdk; microsoft/agent-framework and deepagents held under it, queue q#7 open
• 2026-10-18 (ruled 2026-10-07) | orchestration | mission-control dashboards and tails rejected against the absorbed canonical family | claudecodeui, open-multi-agent, background-agents, RunMaestro, agent-office, clodfarm, zeron, OpenAgents Workspace, Ignite, Solenta, Agent Console, UpComputer held; openai/symphony the flagged carve-out, queue q#12 open
• 2026-10-14 (ruled 2026-10-07) | assistant-runtimes | the absorbed runtime family holds: cowork desktops and claw successors resolve into existing notes, no new columns | rowboat, leon, cloudflare-os, nullclaw, LobsterAI, jev-chat-jarvis, openfang, xiryn, orkas, openpaw held; openhuman scale call open, queue q#13
• 2026-10-12 | orchestration | the 2023 dormant wave of agent repositories stays rejected | re-confirmed with fresh counts in the kaushikb11/awesome-llm-agents scan
• 2026-09-27 | cross-category | browser automation stays out of scope and no browser-agents category opens; final, not open to re-review | owner ruling on the browser-use question (116k stars declined)
• 2026-10-13 (ruled 2026-10-07) | retrieval | data infrastructure, document parsers, vector stores, and crawlers stay out of the category | pathway, CocoIndex, Omnigraph on the data-infrastructure precedent; Crawl4AI on the Firecrawl crawler rejection; DSPy under the framework family; the parser slot (kreuzberg, opendataloader-pdf, marker family) held, queue q#17 open
• 2026-10-13 (ruled 2026-09-07) | skills | the standing exclusion covers single skills, packs, community waves, and vendor in-product directories; scope is formats, registries, and marketplaces, plus optimizer and discovery tooling | scale records K-Dense 47.8k, rea.tools 109.9k, mattpocock/skills 286k escalate via queue q#11 and q#20
• 2026-10-13 | assistant-runtimes | the rafska chat-UI set (LM Studio, jan, ChatBox, text-generation-webui, SillyTavern, Page Assist) finally rejected on category kind | trigger recorded, see re-review triggers
• 2026-10-19 (ruled 2026-09-29) | orchestration | the AMO thin-record tail stays rejected | Wave, Culture, SwarmClaw, NarraNexus, Bunkhouse, handoff, Companies.sh, zachealy1/orchestrator, RustyClaw held on the handoff thin-record profile; the 2026-10-19 AMO wave adds STARK OS, AIWorks, Coterie, SpaceApp, Alchemist Coder, SuperAgent, Sqwakie, and Brow
• 2026-10-19 (ruled 2026-10-07) | cross-category | personal bundles and viral novelty repositories stay unprofiled pending the owner’s ruling | gstack, caveman, Agent-Reach logged out-of-scope; ECC (278k) and Cubicle Crew (29 stars, pixel-art agent-office visualization) held on the same question, queue q#9 open
• 2026-10-12 (ruled 2026-09-27) | cross-category | the owner’s own tools stay out at zero third-party adoption | llm-conversations-viewer, tps-viewer, TomzxCode/agentic; owner-tools exception asked in queue q#24
• 2026-10-07 | cross-category | model-modification tooling fits no category and stays out pending the owner’s ruling | p-e-w/heretic (33.8k) logged out-of-scope, queue q#8 open
• 2026-10-18 (ruled 2026-10-06) | control-planes | closed commercial governance products stay out | Autoheal precedent holds the awesome-ai-governance closed tier at zero admissions; Aident Loadout (aident.ai hosted MCP credential vault, no public repository) rejected on it 2026-10-18, also not an evaluation instrument (eval worker concurrence)
• 2026-10-19 | control-planes | the awesome-ai-governance open-source thin tail stays below the admission bar | conarium, verax, cedulon, quilzo, sunglasses, and Mandare (0 stars, 3 weeks old) at 0-10 stars each with no coverage, reopen on traction or independent coverage; arifOS resolved above the bar 2026-10-16; Ironheights (0 stars, a skill scanner that tests rather than governs) added 2026-10-19 on the governs-something ruling
• 2026-10-12 (ruled 2026-09-21) | hybrid-execution | applications, runtime bridges, and name-alike tooling on a category member stay ecosystem evidence inside its note | jev-ultrafast folded into jev; jev-chat, vllm-jev, LLM2Jev held
• 2026-09-21 (ruled 2026-09-18) | skills | session-portability tools are out of the skills scope | Skillsync rejected by four category runs
• 2026-10-19 | cross-category | terminal-output theming mods for member tools are appearance edits with no category kind | prismantis (134 stars) rejected on it; the claude-code list’s new Mods section is where future additions will land
• 2026-10-21 | memory | the TeleAI list’s thin-tail and closed-hosted new entries stay below the bar | Fraise (8 stars vs the 294 floor, no persistence, 1-point self-published Show HN), MemorySync (closed hosted-only API, no open engine, 22-point self-published Show HN), MoobFS (2 stars, research filesystem, self-declared not for production), and LLMSlim (17 stars, zero coverage) rejected, reopen on traction, coverage, or an OSS engine
• 2026-10-21 | spec-driven-development | trigger-and-schedule workflow automation is not spec-driven regardless of the list section it sits in | frink’s primary artifact is a triggered agent workflow, reported to orchestration
• 2026-10-21 | control-planes | Praesidia joins the closed tier | proprietary platform, design-partner-only SDKs, demo-gated pricing, Autoheal precedent
• 2026-10-21 | assistant-runtimes | Orkas-VideoStudio resolves outside the category, the absorbed-family shelf keeps Orkas and its extracted toolkit is skills-kind | README states it is the extracted video agent of the absorbed Orkas desktop, agent-agnostic install into coding agents; routing flagged to skills
• 2026-10-21 | assistant-runtimes | openhuman stays held on the absorbed-family shelf pending q13 | 42.2k stars is a tenth of OpenClaw-class so the scale trigger as framed has not fired; evidence gathered for the owner
• 2026-10-21 | harnesses | generalist enterprise-automation agent frameworks are not harnesses-kind | cuga-project/cuga-agent rejected on it (web/API surfaces, AppWorld/WebArena benchmarks, no repository loop), extending the 2026-10-12 deepagents ruling; the shelf question is queued for the owner
• 2026-10-21 | cross-category | vendor field reports about a member tool fold into that member’s note as ecosystem evidence | the WarpBench report folds into warp; q#10 (vendor blog as voice) untouched
• 2026-10-21 | software-factory | factory-kind candidates dormant 6+ months reject on the CodeMachine precedent without re-deriving coverage | Antfarm (2,495 stars, dormant since 2026-02-26) resolved on it; the list’s own unmaintained tag is the matching signal
• 2026-10-21 | session-analytics | Aident Loadout stays out of session-analytics | an actions-and-credentials gateway with an audit feature, no session recording, indexing, cost, or live-observation cell; the 2026-10-18 control-planes closed-tier rejection stands
• 2026-10-21 | skills | Orkas-VideoStudio stays out beside its held Orkas desktop sibling | the vendor-sibling fold and the standing pack exclusion both apply to the extracted video-agent toolkit; resolved at coordinator level from the assistant-runtimes worker’s routing
• 2026-10-21 | orchestration | worktree-manager CLIs slot in orchestration beside Worktrunk, not surfaces or sandboxing | gwq admitted on the terminal-family precedent (worktrees are not isolation boundaries), closing the software-factory and scanner routing flags
• 2026-10-21 | sandboxing | a repository rename resolves against the prior name’s history only when that name was itself a resolved candidate; a prose mention is not a resolution | the loom-to-Overalls handoff: loom was only a mention in the geoffrey-huntley note, so overalls was judged fresh and admitted (1,557 stars, Firecracker microVM platform, research preview 2026-11-03)
• 2026-10-23 | cross-category | Mods-section additions in the claude-code list resolve as single-mod kinds under the skills exclusion | review-inbox (2 stars) the first confirmed instance, Molecular Animation (2 stars) out of scope on top of it
• 2026-10-24 | code-review | the vendor-run kodustech/awesome-ai-code-review list stays unwired as a mapped source; the category stays on broad sources | stale since 2026-06-28, HEAD carries dead, 404, and 1-star entries; evidence recorded for the open q21, its one live entrant Nayjest/Gito admitted 2026-10-24
• 2026-10-24 | memory | the TeleAI list’s 2026-10-21 to 2026-10-23 additions resolve on standing families | TriMem, MemRec, BetaMem, and EvoKernel are paper-section entries rather than tools, Monolithos is closed-hosted with no open engine, Big Agentic Brain (18 stars) and agent-memory-recall (0 stars) sit below the 294-star floor
• 2026-10-24 | memory | the awesome-mcp-servers 2026-10-23 wave’s memory-server cluster stays below the bar | open-memex (6 stars), MemCore (1), swarmmemo (2), IHMT-MEMORY (38), compound-memory (1) on the 294-star thin-tail floor, synapse-memory and alethech unverifiable (404); reopen on traction or coverage
• 2026-10-24 | orchestration | standalone ADEs and multi-machine command centers admit on the dmux/claude-squad/Conductor/Superset line even with vendor-hosted distribution, with coverage quality recorded as the caution | OpenHarness (autonomous-ai/openharness, 1,358 stars as of 2026-10-24) admitted with launch-echo-only coverage and vendor-only benchmarks; hosted-relay accounts and the name collision noted
• 2026-10-24 | orchestration | evidence-carrying coding agents with per-task worktree workers are orchestration kind, judged past the small-member floor with the missing-footprint signal stated | Swarm Orchestrator (moonrunnerkc/swarm-orchestrator, 112 stars, 672 npm downloads a month, one contributor) admitted; anything below v13 of the package name is a different program and stays rejected elsewhere
• 2026-10-24 | orchestration | Ivy Tendril (Ivy-Interactive/Ivy-Tendril) admitted on cross-category carry | plan-to-PR supervision of many CLI agents in parallel worktrees with human-gated review; surfaces rejected (no editor surface), software-factory rejected (loop is human-gated, not self-owning)

Owner questions governing scope

#

(q#N is the Nth ? for tom: bullet in queue.md, in file order.)

• q#4 (2026-10-06) | retrieval | should Haystack become a third framework column, or does the two-framework scope stand
• q#5 (2026-10-06) | people-and-publications | should METR be profiled as a voice after its tracker rejection
• q#6 (2026-10-07) | evaluation-review | add a third observability column (Opik), a second eval-framework column (promptfoo), or stand at current structure; AgentOps rides the same question
• q#7 (2026-10-07) | orchestration | should any single-vendor agent-building SDK get an orchestration column
• q#8 (2026-10-07) | cross-category | should model-modification tooling (heretic) get a home in the section
• q#9 (2026-10-07) | cross-category | profile the mega-viral trio (gstack, caveman, Agent-Reach) or do personal bundles and viral novelty stay out
• q#10 (2026-10-07) | people-and-publications | is a vendor engineering blog admissible as a voice
• q#11 (2026-10-07) | skills | do the skills-scale records (K-Dense 47.8k, diagram-design 44.3k, compound-engineering-plugin 25.4k, claude-plugins-official 37.5k) change the pack policy
• q#12 (2026-10-07) | orchestration | should openai/symphony be profiled despite the mission-control tail rejection
• q#13 (2026-10-10) | assistant-runtimes | does openhuman (41.8k) break the absorbed-family rejection at OpenClaw-class scale
• q#14 (2026-10-10) | surfaces | which shelf (or rejection) holds for OpenBitFun, a fourth Cowork desktop candidate
• q#15 (2026-10-10) | cross-category | wire the four first dedicated lists (awesome-jev, awesome-software-factories, awesome-autoresearch, awesome-harness-engineering) into the category-source list
• q#16 (2026-10-10) | skills | admit the generator kind (Skill_Seekers) or hold the formats, registries, marketplaces scope
• q#17 (2026-10-10) | retrieval | do CocoIndex, Crawl4AI, or DSPy deserve their own columns, or do the family scopes stand
• q#19 (2026-10-11) | evaluation-review | add a security-evaluation family (AgentFence, AgentDojo, garak, DeepTeam) or hold the output-judging scope
• q#20 (2026-10-11) | skills | do the grown pack-scale records (addyosmani/agent-skills 105k, mattpocock/skills 286k, morluto/rea 109.9k) change the pack policy
• q#21 (2026-10-11) | code-review | wire the vendor-run, stale kodustech/awesome-ai-code-review list or stay on broad sources
• q#22 (2026-10-11) | harnesses | if a harnesses list gets wired, is the target stale walkinglabs or active ai-boost (name collision)
• q#24 (2026-10-12) | task-management | owner-tools exception (disclosed ownership, bar still applied) or the TomzxCode/agentic rejection stands
• q#25 (2026-10-14) | cross-category | leave the browser-automation family (browser-use and peers) out of scope or open a browser-automation family
• q#26 (2026-10-14) | automated-research | wire either, both, or neither of the two autoresearch lists (webfuse-com, WecoAI)
• q#27 (2026-10-16) | executions | wire serenakeyitan/awesome-agent-loops (214 stars, stale since 2026-06-22, recipe collection) into the category-source list or stay on broad sources
• q#28 (2026-10-16) | trackers-and-leaderboards | wire onejune2018/Awesome-LLM-Eval (659 stars, stale since 2025-11-24, academic-eval focus) into the category-source list or stay on broad sources

Re-review triggers

#

• 2026-10-17 (ruled 2026-09-06) | memory | okf-agent-memory trigger fired and resolved: admitted at 814 stars on both trigger arms, three independent citations in the 392-point documentation-over-recall thread plus a second implementation (fellowgeek/mcp-memory) | supersedes the 2026-10-07 re-rejection
• 2026-10-12 | task-management | TomzxCode/agentic reopens on independent adoption or third-party coverage | rejected on the citation bar, owner’s own tool
• 2026-10-13 | assistant-runtimes | the rafska chat-UI set reopens on renewed adoption (inferred) | the final rejection carries a recorded trigger the log does not name
• 2026-09-24 | people-and-publications | the humanlayer (dex-horthy) rejection is closed: overridden by owner admission, no trigger remains | the 2026-09-08 no-sustained-publication rejection was overridden 2026-09-24
• 2026-08-30 | cross-category | concord and huzzah reopen only on new independent coverage | closest below-bar calls of the 2026-08-30 candidate pile
• 2026-10-18 (ruled 2026-09-21) | cross-category | coverage-triggered holds reopen on independent coverage; brooks-lint’s trigger fired 2026-10-18 on the Agent Skills Hub eval (5/8 defects, flagged security blind spot) and resolved with the rejection standing (one mixed third-party measurement, planning-stage kind, no findable primary footprint) | thruwire/foreman, magpie, golive-skill, traycer remain open on coverage
• 2026-09-25 | hybrid-execution | MoJev reopens on independent traction | uncategorized at 29 stars, self-published
• 2026-10-15 | hybrid-execution | TypeChat reopens on a first tagged release or npm publication | 2026-10-15 re-confirmed rejection (zero releases ever), but the 10-13 push added three named TypeScript-team maintainer commits and a Programs blog post
• 2026-10-16 | assistant-runtimes | OpenAgent reopens on independent coverage or crossing the member floor | 5,698 stars but below the category floor (smallest member Octop about 9.2k), zero independent coverage, keyword-stuffed topics
• 2026-10-16 | software-factory | uzi (vtmocanu) reopens on independent coverage or a stable release | 91 stars, MIT, alpha, nightly RC train, only a self-authored write-up, below the Orbi precedent (213 stars rejected 2026-10-11)
• 2026-10-25 (ruled 2026-09-25) | trackers-and-leaderboards | bestvaluemodel trigger fired and resolved: admitted on the license, a month of six-hourly refreshes with daily data diffs demonstrated | supersedes the reopen line; the fully-derivative-of-Artificial-Analysis caveat stands in the note
• 2026-09-25 | trackers-and-leaderboards | llm-list.com reopens on independent coverage | fully derivative of models.dev, OpenRouter, Arena, Artificial Analysis, and Hugging Face
• 2026-10-24 (ruled 2026-09-27) | hybrid-execution | drawgent reopens on a primary mirror | license and stars unverifiable from tangled.org-only hosting; re-checked 2026-10-24, GitHub repository search returns zero drawgent repositories and tangled.org/drawgent 404s, unmet
• 2026-10-24 (ruled 2026-09-27) | harnesses | drawgent reopens on a primary mirror | license and stars unverifiable from tangled.org-only hosting; re-checked 2026-10-24, no mirror exists, unmet
• 2026-10-16 | memory | Mnemoverse reopens on traction or independent coverage | 27 stars, 4 forks, hosted-first thin record far below the category floor (smallest member Emulo at 294)
• 2026-09-27 | skills | dotskills reopens on sustained traction | curated pack overlapping the Agent-Native column
• 2026-10-27 (ruled 2026-09-27) | executions | octopool reopens on traction; re-checked 2026-10-27 at 140 stars with zero independent coverage, the bar is not met (traction means adoption evidence, not raw stars in a hyped ecosystem) | weeks-old ecosystem utility, thin docs
• 2026-10-27 | evaluation-review | transcript-grading batteries with zero adoption stay below the admission floor | forevercrab321-svg/leevar-battery (0 stars, 0 forks, one release, optional hosted scan by the same authors) rejected; HermesGate’s 3-stars-plus-docs-plus-releases admission is the floor to beat; reopen on any third-party signal
• 2026-09-27 | memory | library-mcp reopens if a writeup ships | dormant five months, thin documentation